DEATH AND CONSOLATION
Death, of course, has been a major theme of the Bush administration, so immediately after announcing he would spit in the eye of the electorate and escalate the war in Iraq, George presented the Medal of Honor to the grieving parents of 23 year-old fallen hero, Cpl. Jason Dunham at a White House ceremony. Consolation is one of the services provided by God and His spokespeople, so it only seemed natural that our Born Again knight be seen as the Chief Consoler. Tearing up, the president offered the Dunham's his condolences, did the solemn thing with his lips, exchanged hugs and kisses, and chivalrously showed them the door.
Consolation has religious underpinnings, and warring leaders must use it to maintain morale. A soldier who fears death is a bad soldier. Parents who fear death make bad parents of dead soldiers. Religion offers military commanders a way through this logistical quagmire.
The Roman Catholic Church, to single out one, has always sold consolation and prayers. After scaring us half to death with the notion of sin, hell, and purgatory, religion offers the antidote to it's own malady, in the form of consolation.
Back in the middle ages, the Church sold "indulgences" for money, issuing signed certificates specifying the number of days you were in remission in purgatory -- that hellish half-way house where dead souls go for remedial tweaking before entering the "sin-free" zone of heaven. In the Church's own version of the Nigerian Internet scam, the rich could afford to buy parole from purgatory. Prayers could also be bought, and for the right price, you could provide for your soul in perpetuity.
Since 95 percent of Americans believe they will survive death, it is a wonder they even need consolation to get over it. Why not celebrate and throw parties? Congratulations should be offered the dying: after all, they'll be in the loving hands of God. The Muslim idea of martyrdom is a perfect example, and certainly one that George Bush experienced as he sat reading "The Pet Goat" while the world was falling apart around him.
Strangely, religion seems not to be the great comfort it's made out to be. Indeed, the opposite turns out to be the case. Surveys show that religious folk fear death far more than non-believers. And this manifests itself on the political scene. It is always the religious nuts who condemn the peaceful, painless transition offered by euthanasia, or assisted suicide, when there is no hope of a cure. You would think the religious folks would be the last people to cling unbecomingly to earthly life.
Atheists approach death very differently. They have nothing to fear, because fear was not front-loaded into their operating systems. Instead, they appreciate the gift of life, realizing that every day must be lived to the utmost precisely because it is finite. Squandering life through belief in dogma, or war, is the only sin in their belief system. And death is nothing to worry about. As Mark Twain so aptly put it:
"I do not fear death. I had been dead for billions and billions of years before I was born, and had not suffered the slightest inconvenience from it."
Death, of course, has been a major theme of the Bush administration, so immediately after announcing he would spit in the eye of the electorate and escalate the war in Iraq, George presented the Medal of Honor to the grieving parents of 23 year-old fallen hero, Cpl. Jason Dunham at a White House ceremony. Consolation is one of the services provided by God and His spokespeople, so it only seemed natural that our Born Again knight be seen as the Chief Consoler. Tearing up, the president offered the Dunham's his condolences, did the solemn thing with his lips, exchanged hugs and kisses, and chivalrously showed them the door.
Consolation has religious underpinnings, and warring leaders must use it to maintain morale. A soldier who fears death is a bad soldier. Parents who fear death make bad parents of dead soldiers. Religion offers military commanders a way through this logistical quagmire.
The Roman Catholic Church, to single out one, has always sold consolation and prayers. After scaring us half to death with the notion of sin, hell, and purgatory, religion offers the antidote to it's own malady, in the form of consolation.
Back in the middle ages, the Church sold "indulgences" for money, issuing signed certificates specifying the number of days you were in remission in purgatory -- that hellish half-way house where dead souls go for remedial tweaking before entering the "sin-free" zone of heaven. In the Church's own version of the Nigerian Internet scam, the rich could afford to buy parole from purgatory. Prayers could also be bought, and for the right price, you could provide for your soul in perpetuity.
Since 95 percent of Americans believe they will survive death, it is a wonder they even need consolation to get over it. Why not celebrate and throw parties? Congratulations should be offered the dying: after all, they'll be in the loving hands of God. The Muslim idea of martyrdom is a perfect example, and certainly one that George Bush experienced as he sat reading "The Pet Goat" while the world was falling apart around him.
Strangely, religion seems not to be the great comfort it's made out to be. Indeed, the opposite turns out to be the case. Surveys show that religious folk fear death far more than non-believers. And this manifests itself on the political scene. It is always the religious nuts who condemn the peaceful, painless transition offered by euthanasia, or assisted suicide, when there is no hope of a cure. You would think the religious folks would be the last people to cling unbecomingly to earthly life.
Atheists approach death very differently. They have nothing to fear, because fear was not front-loaded into their operating systems. Instead, they appreciate the gift of life, realizing that every day must be lived to the utmost precisely because it is finite. Squandering life through belief in dogma, or war, is the only sin in their belief system. And death is nothing to worry about. As Mark Twain so aptly put it:
"I do not fear death. I had been dead for billions and billions of years before I was born, and had not suffered the slightest inconvenience from it."
13 Comments:
Twain's quote is priceless. But when it comes to atheism and piety, never the twain shall meet. Pity.
enjoyed your column today. Americans must have sinned terribly to deserve George Bush as their fate. That there is apparently no practical way to stop him tells me their is an essential flaw in our constitution.
Almost got scared off by the title. I found this uplifting. My only complaint is that I won't be seeing Twain in the next life.
Loved this piece – I so admire your William Safire-level ability to cast a clever line. (viz “sin-free zone.” I get it.)
The essay took a turn I didn’t expect, but I always enjoy some religion bashing. I was expecting an attack on the Iraquagmire from the perspective of those who are sacrificing for this folly. When I saw the picture of Bush giving the grieving family a consolation prize, I imagined a scenario in which the wife/mother said, “Mr. President, this attractive award may be suitable for framing, but it is NOT a suitable substitute for the death of our beloved. Stop the war, bring the troops home now.” And THEN they would be shown the door.
r
r, I'm sure grieving parents are well screened to assure that a Cindy Sheehan would not throw off their sheep’s clothing.
Rick, another gem! What a relief we have knowing history will be the only judgement we will face.
I am taking a quick break from a very intense poker game I've been playing for the last five years with these two middle Eastern foreign exchange students and wanted to get your advice on what you think of my strategy. My brother tells me you're a pretty good poker player and know a thing or two about such things.
I had watched some of those cable show poker tournaments and saw how effective bluffing can be, so I thought I'd stick my neck out and stay the course on what is really a pretty crappy hand: 2 diamonds, 4 spades, 7 hearts, 9 clubs, and the 10 diamonds. (When the hand was first dealt, I was pretty confident I could draw to a straight.) At any rate, I thought I'd try some of those techniques I had seen on those tournament shows, like looking my opponent in the eyes with steely resolve, the occasional "tsk tsk" at their raises, accompanied by a condescending smirk and laugh with the audacious tone, that kind of thing.
Meanwhile, these two foreign exchange students from the middle east, "Sou Knee" and "Shee Ite", seem to mock me. They look at each other and laugh at my every move. And for every move I made, they'd laugh at me and counter it with another raise. They seem to know something I don't and I even think they're cheating. Quite frankly, it's starting to rattle me a bit.
Well, now I'm down to my last 20,000, so I figured I'd go "all in." This is it, man. I'm a little nervous about what my fiancee, co-workers, and extended friends and family are going to think of me if this bluff doesn't intimidate my two opponents into caving in and realizing that I truly do have the better hand than they do, when in fact I'm pretty sure I don't.
So, given your experience with such matters, do you think I can win by going all in (on what is actually nothing more than a desperate move to convince these guys I have the superior hand), or do you think I should pull out altogether? I mean, jeez, I've commited so much for way too long...it seems foolish for me to quit now. I really, really, hate to lose and be proven wrong..it really bugs me.
I need your reply pretty quickly...we're on an agreed-upon bathroom break and it's gettin' a bit "hairy" now.
On second thought, who am I kidding? I've never listened to anyone's advice before. Never mind. I'm the decider.
They're back at the table now and sound pretty angry. They're even yelling at each other! I think they're cracking. I think I have a chance to win this thing after all!!!
I'll let you know how it goes. I feel better already!
Well Rob, I'm not much of a poker player, but rather than taking prophylactic measures, I prefer pulling out. Why take chances with the "Sou Knees" and "Shee Ites" of the world, when you're doubling down on a bad hand. You don't want to do what Woody Allen and Moktada did and screw the Sou Knees behind the Mia's back.
I've heard that when families come and he "hugs" them he runs his hands up and down the back to make sure they aren't wired. Everything is always about him.
Momma Mia! That was wicked. You go get baptized right now!
You mean that "scared to death" routine--in planes, cars, elevators, conference rooms--is just an act?
(Regarding Bush checking people ro wires) It is in one of my many documentaries and one I watched recently, so I'll figure out which one. It might be Barrie Zweicker The Great Conspiracy. If so I can give you his email. Hopefully I can get the answer over the weekend. Whoever said it had interviewed family members and was told this by multiple people.
Remember how he ran his hands over the German chancellor. Can you imagine......
It's that Martini guy again. He must get lonely on his blog site. The sarcophagus at Chernobyl gets more visitors.
Post a Comment
<< Home